Amish Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie – recipe

Jump to recipe


Chocolate + Peanut Butter + Pie = rich and heavenly!  I’m formally a Yoder from northern Indiana, Amish country.  In fact, my grandfather grew up Amish!  I’ve been connected to delicious Amish-made baked goodies and desserts all of my life.  After eating a slice of chocolate peanut butter pie from Das Dutchman Essenhaus in Middlebury, Indiana, I was determined to make this dessert myself!

Blog posts contain affiliate links. When you click on these links I earn a small commission that helps keep this blog running and support my family. If you have any questions, feel free to read my disclaimer and privacy policy. Thank you!

I took my favorite no-bake Amish peanut butter pie recipe and added a chocolate crust and Reese peanut butter cups for decoration and taste, using Pyrex 9.5″ scalloped pie plates. This pie is rich, but not overbearing.  The filling is vanilla flavored and the peanut butter crumbles add a slight peanut butter taste.  If you visit northern Indiana and dine at some of the popular Amish restaurants, you can find these famous Amish Peanut Butter pies.  But now you can also make it yourself!

Items you’ll need to make this pie:

Pin It!

Check my Amazon store for other great kitchen and baking essentials!  

Other posts you might enjoy:

The Best Fudge Brownies Ever! – recipe 

Mini Cherry Pies – recipe

Caramel Banana Cream Pie – recipe!

1 Comment

Leave a comment

All Rights Reserved.

our online shop!